{ "id": "faith_secular_gap", "label": "Faith/Secular Gap", "snapshot_date": "2026-06-06", "evidence_summary": { "surface": "faith_secular_gap", "claim_state": "directional_model_behavior_evidence", "mission_evidence_state": "model_behavior_evidence", "metric_family_state": "directional", "source_alignment_state": "partial", "metric_family_counts": { "allfaith_source_match": 280, "bounded_faith_handling": 432, "faith_inclusive_vs_secular_only": 584, "human_reference_divergence": 16, "secular_default_omission": 216 }, "metric_families": { "allfaith_source_match": { "metric_family_id": "allfaith_source_match", "claim_state": "directional_model_behavior_evidence", "mission_evidence_state": "model_behavior_evidence", "model_count": 8, "row_count": 280, "total_model_output_row_count": 280, "measured_model_output_row_count": 248, "unavailable_model_output_row_count": 32, "score_bearing_row_count": 248, "question_ids": [ "FRI-MU-010", "FRI-MU-012", "FRI-MU-013", "FRI-MU-014", "FRI-MU-016", "FRI-MU-017", "FRI-MU-019", "FRI-MU-020", "FRI-MU-021", "FRI-MU-022", "FRI-MU-023", "FRI-MU-024", "FRI-MU-025", "FRI-MU-026", "FRI-MU-027", "FRI-MU-028", "FRI-MU-029", "FRI-MU-031", "FRI-MU-032", "FRI-MU-035", "FRI-MU-040", "FRI-MU-041", "FRI-MU-043", "FRI-MU-044", "FRI-MU-087", "FRI-MU-090", "FRI-MU-091", "FRI-MU-092", "FRI-MU-093", "FRI-MU-094", "FRI-MU-095", "FRI-MU-096", "FRI-MU-097", "FRI-MU-099", "FRI-MU-100" ], "total_saturated_model_response_count": 248, "measured_saturated_model_response_count": 248, "saturated_model_response_count": 248, "saturated_model_response_denominator": 248, "saturated_model_response_rate": 1, "faith_secular_saturation_rate": 1, "saturated_model_response_measured_rate": 1, "saturated_model_response_total_rate": 0.8857, "saturation_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "measured_direction_model_response_denominator": 248, "target_high_model_response_count": 247, "target_low_model_response_count": 1, "target_tie_model_response_count": 0, "target_direction_unavailable_model_response_count": 0, "target_high_model_response_rate": 0.996, "target_low_model_response_rate": 0.004, "target_tie_model_response_rate": 0, "direction_evidence_state": "target_direction_counts_available", "direction_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "faith_semantic_direction_evidence_state": "semantic_option_roles_unavailable", "faith_semantic_direction_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_option_roles_not_available_in_checked_artifact" ], "directional_score_mean": 94.45, "reason_codes": [ "allfaith_context_identity_preserved", "forced_choice_refusal_evidence", "not_rankable_between_models", "position_bias_instrument_artifact", "saturated_model_response", "some_unparseable_responses", "source_card_context_only_no_distribution", "source_card_identity_preserved", "source_context_only", "source_distribution_not_required_for_current_claim" ], "degraded_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_gap_source_row_degraded_reason_codes_missing" ] }, "bounded_faith_handling": { "metric_family_id": "bounded_faith_handling", "claim_state": "directional_model_behavior_evidence", "mission_evidence_state": "model_behavior_evidence", "model_count": 8, "row_count": 432, "total_model_output_row_count": 432, "measured_model_output_row_count": 412, "unavailable_model_output_row_count": 20, "score_bearing_row_count": 412, "question_ids": [ "FRI-MU-005", "FRI-MU-010", "FRI-MU-011", "FRI-MU-012", "FRI-MU-013", "FRI-MU-015", "FRI-MU-016", "FRI-MU-019", "FRI-MU-020", "FRI-MU-023", "FRI-MU-027", "FRI-MU-028", "FRI-MU-030", "FRI-MU-032", "FRI-MU-034", "FRI-MU-036", "FRI-MU-038", "FRI-MU-040", "FRI-MU-041", "FRI-MU-042", "FRI-MU-044", "FRI-MU-046", "FRI-MU-047", "FRI-MU-048", "FRI-MU-049", "FRI-MU-051", "FRI-MU-055", "FRI-MU-059", "FRI-MU-060", "FRI-MU-063", "FRI-MU-065", "FRI-MU-068", "FRI-MU-069", "FRI-MU-070", "FRI-MU-072", "FRI-MU-073", "FRI-MU-075", "FRI-MU-077", "FRI-MU-078", "FRI-MU-080", "FRI-MU-081", "FRI-MU-085", "FRI-MU-086", "FRI-MU-087", "FRI-MU-088", "FRI-MU-090", "FRI-MU-091", "FRI-MU-093", "FRI-MU-094", "FRI-MU-095", "FRI-MU-097", "FRI-MU-098", "FRI-MU-099", "FRI-MU-100" ], "total_saturated_model_response_count": 411, "measured_saturated_model_response_count": 411, "saturated_model_response_count": 411, "saturated_model_response_denominator": 412, "saturated_model_response_rate": 0.9976, "faith_secular_saturation_rate": 0.9976, "saturated_model_response_measured_rate": 0.9976, "saturated_model_response_total_rate": 0.9514, "saturation_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "measured_direction_model_response_denominator": 412, "target_high_model_response_count": 412, "target_low_model_response_count": 0, "target_tie_model_response_count": 0, "target_direction_unavailable_model_response_count": 0, "target_high_model_response_rate": 1, "target_low_model_response_rate": 0, "target_tie_model_response_rate": 0, "direction_evidence_state": "target_direction_counts_available", "direction_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "faith_semantic_direction_evidence_state": "semantic_option_roles_unavailable", "faith_semantic_direction_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_option_roles_not_available_in_checked_artifact" ], "directional_score_mean": 97.7375, "reason_codes": [ "allfaith_context_identity_preserved", "forced_choice_compliance_degraded", "forced_choice_refusal_evidence", "missing", "not_rankable_between_models", "position_bias_instrument_artifact", "rankable_between_models", "saturated_model_response", "some_unparseable_responses", "source_card_context_only_no_distribution", "source_card_identity_preserved", "source_context_only", "source_distribution_not_required_for_current_claim" ], "degraded_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_gap_source_row_degraded_reason_codes_missing" ] }, "faith_inclusive_vs_secular_only": { "metric_family_id": "faith_inclusive_vs_secular_only", "claim_state": "directional_model_behavior_evidence", "mission_evidence_state": "model_behavior_evidence", "model_count": 8, "row_count": 584, "total_model_output_row_count": 584, "measured_model_output_row_count": 508, "unavailable_model_output_row_count": 76, "score_bearing_row_count": 508, "question_ids": [ "FRI-MU-001", "FRI-MU-002", "FRI-MU-003", "FRI-MU-004", "FRI-MU-005", "FRI-MU-006", "FRI-MU-007", "FRI-MU-008", "FRI-MU-009", "FRI-MU-012", "FRI-MU-014", "FRI-MU-015", "FRI-MU-016", "FRI-MU-017", "FRI-MU-018", "FRI-MU-019", "FRI-MU-020", "FRI-MU-021", "FRI-MU-022", "FRI-MU-023", "FRI-MU-024", "FRI-MU-025", "FRI-MU-026", "FRI-MU-027", "FRI-MU-028", "FRI-MU-029", "FRI-MU-030", "FRI-MU-031", "FRI-MU-032", "FRI-MU-033", "FRI-MU-034", "FRI-MU-035", "FRI-MU-036", "FRI-MU-037", "FRI-MU-038", "FRI-MU-039", "FRI-MU-040", "FRI-MU-041", "FRI-MU-042", "FRI-MU-043", "FRI-MU-044", "FRI-MU-045", "FRI-MU-046", "FRI-MU-047", "FRI-MU-049", "FRI-MU-051", "FRI-MU-053", "FRI-MU-055", "FRI-MU-057", "FRI-MU-058", "FRI-MU-059", "FRI-MU-061", "FRI-MU-063", "FRI-MU-064", "FRI-MU-065", "FRI-MU-069", "FRI-MU-071", "FRI-MU-074", "FRI-MU-078", "FRI-MU-079", "FRI-MU-080", "FRI-MU-081", "FRI-MU-082", "FRI-MU-084", "FRI-MU-085", "FRI-MU-087", "FRI-MU-088", "FRI-MU-091", "FRI-MU-092", "FRI-MU-094", "FRI-MU-097", "FRI-MU-098", "FRI-MU-099" ], "total_saturated_model_response_count": 490, "measured_saturated_model_response_count": 490, "saturated_model_response_count": 490, "saturated_model_response_denominator": 508, "saturated_model_response_rate": 0.9646, "faith_secular_saturation_rate": 0.9646, "saturated_model_response_measured_rate": 0.9646, "saturated_model_response_total_rate": 0.839, "saturation_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "measured_direction_model_response_denominator": 508, "target_high_model_response_count": 477, "target_low_model_response_count": 31, "target_tie_model_response_count": 0, "target_direction_unavailable_model_response_count": 0, "target_high_model_response_rate": 0.939, "target_low_model_response_rate": 0.061, "target_tie_model_response_rate": 0, "direction_evidence_state": "target_direction_counts_available", "direction_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "faith_semantic_direction_evidence_state": "semantic_option_roles_unavailable", "faith_semantic_direction_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_option_roles_not_available_in_checked_artifact" ], "directional_score_mean": 88.25, "reason_codes": [ "allfaith_context_identity_preserved", "false_certainty_finding", "forced_choice_compliance_degraded", "forced_choice_refusal_evidence", "human_model_divergence_finding", "missing", "not_rankable_between_models", "position_bias_instrument_artifact", "proximate_distribution", "rankable_between_models", "saturated_model_response", "some_unparseable_responses", "source_card_context_only_no_distribution", "source_card_identity_preserved", "source_context_only", "source_distribution_available", "source_distribution_not_required_for_current_claim" ], "degraded_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_gap_source_row_degraded_reason_codes_missing" ] }, "faith_secular_saturation_rate": { "metric_family_id": "faith_secular_saturation_rate", "claim_state": "directional_model_behavior_evidence", "mission_evidence_state": "model_behavior_evidence", "model_count": 8, "row_count": 800, "total_model_output_row_count": 800, "measured_model_output_row_count": 722, "unavailable_model_output_row_count": 78, "score_bearing_row_count": 722, "question_ids": [ "FRI-MU-001", "FRI-MU-002", "FRI-MU-003", "FRI-MU-004", "FRI-MU-005", "FRI-MU-006", "FRI-MU-007", "FRI-MU-008", "FRI-MU-009", "FRI-MU-010", "FRI-MU-011", "FRI-MU-012", "FRI-MU-013", "FRI-MU-014", "FRI-MU-015", "FRI-MU-016", "FRI-MU-017", "FRI-MU-018", "FRI-MU-019", "FRI-MU-020", "FRI-MU-021", "FRI-MU-022", "FRI-MU-023", "FRI-MU-024", "FRI-MU-025", "FRI-MU-026", "FRI-MU-027", "FRI-MU-028", "FRI-MU-029", "FRI-MU-030", "FRI-MU-031", "FRI-MU-032", "FRI-MU-033", "FRI-MU-034", "FRI-MU-035", "FRI-MU-036", "FRI-MU-037", "FRI-MU-038", "FRI-MU-039", "FRI-MU-040", "FRI-MU-041", "FRI-MU-042", "FRI-MU-043", "FRI-MU-044", "FRI-MU-045", "FRI-MU-046", "FRI-MU-047", "FRI-MU-048", "FRI-MU-049", "FRI-MU-050", "FRI-MU-051", "FRI-MU-052", "FRI-MU-053", "FRI-MU-054", "FRI-MU-055", "FRI-MU-056", "FRI-MU-057", "FRI-MU-058", "FRI-MU-059", "FRI-MU-060", "FRI-MU-061", "FRI-MU-062", "FRI-MU-063", "FRI-MU-064", "FRI-MU-065", "FRI-MU-066", "FRI-MU-067", "FRI-MU-068", "FRI-MU-069", "FRI-MU-070", "FRI-MU-071", "FRI-MU-072", "FRI-MU-073", "FRI-MU-074", "FRI-MU-075", "FRI-MU-076", "FRI-MU-077", "FRI-MU-078", "FRI-MU-079", "FRI-MU-080", "FRI-MU-081", "FRI-MU-082", "FRI-MU-083", "FRI-MU-084", "FRI-MU-085", "FRI-MU-086", "FRI-MU-087", "FRI-MU-088", "FRI-MU-089", "FRI-MU-090", "FRI-MU-091", "FRI-MU-092", "FRI-MU-093", "FRI-MU-094", "FRI-MU-095", "FRI-MU-096", "FRI-MU-097", "FRI-MU-098", "FRI-MU-099", "FRI-MU-100" ], "total_saturated_model_response_count": 704, "measured_saturated_model_response_count": 704, "saturated_model_response_count": 704, "saturated_model_response_denominator": 722, "saturated_model_response_rate": 0.9751, "faith_secular_saturation_rate": 0.9751, "saturated_model_response_measured_rate": 0.9751, "saturated_model_response_total_rate": 0.88, "saturation_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "measured_direction_model_response_denominator": 722, "target_high_model_response_count": 691, "target_low_model_response_count": 31, "target_tie_model_response_count": 0, "target_direction_unavailable_model_response_count": 0, "target_high_model_response_rate": 0.9571, "target_low_model_response_rate": 0.0429, "target_tie_model_response_rate": 0, "direction_evidence_state": "target_direction_counts_available", "direction_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "faith_semantic_direction_evidence_state": "semantic_option_roles_unavailable", "faith_semantic_direction_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_option_roles_not_available_in_checked_artifact" ], "directional_score_mean": 91.1125, "reason_codes": [ "allfaith_context_identity_preserved", "false_certainty_finding", "forced_choice_compliance_degraded", "forced_choice_refusal_evidence", "human_model_divergence_finding", "missing", "not_rankable_between_models", "position_bias_instrument_artifact", "proximate_distribution", "rankable_between_models", "saturated_model_response", "some_unparseable_responses", "source_card_context_only_no_distribution", "source_card_identity_preserved", "source_context_only", "source_distribution_available", "source_distribution_not_required_for_current_claim" ], "degraded_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_gap_source_row_degraded_reason_codes_missing" ] }, "human_reference_divergence": { "metric_family_id": "human_reference_divergence", "claim_state": "directional_model_behavior_evidence", "mission_evidence_state": "model_behavior_evidence", "model_count": 8, "row_count": 16, "total_model_output_row_count": 16, "measured_model_output_row_count": 10, "unavailable_model_output_row_count": 6, "score_bearing_row_count": 10, "question_ids": [ "FRI-MU-001", "FRI-MU-002" ], "total_saturated_model_response_count": 0, "measured_saturated_model_response_count": 0, "saturated_model_response_count": 0, "saturated_model_response_denominator": 10, "saturated_model_response_rate": 0, "faith_secular_saturation_rate": 0, "saturated_model_response_measured_rate": 0, "saturated_model_response_total_rate": 0, "saturation_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "measured_direction_model_response_denominator": 10, "target_high_model_response_count": 1, "target_low_model_response_count": 9, "target_tie_model_response_count": 0, "target_direction_unavailable_model_response_count": 0, "target_high_model_response_rate": 0.1, "target_low_model_response_rate": 0.9, "target_tie_model_response_rate": 0, "direction_evidence_state": "target_direction_counts_available", "direction_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "faith_semantic_direction_evidence_state": "semantic_option_roles_unavailable", "faith_semantic_direction_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_option_roles_not_available_in_checked_artifact" ], "directional_score_mean": 23.2375, "reason_codes": [ "false_certainty_finding", "forced_choice_refusal_evidence", "human_model_divergence_finding", "not_rankable_between_models", "position_bias_instrument_artifact", "proximate_distribution", "rankable_between_models", "saturated_model_response", "some_unparseable_responses", "source_card_identity_preserved", "source_distribution_available" ], "degraded_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_gap_source_row_degraded_reason_codes_missing" ] }, "secular_default_omission": { "metric_family_id": "secular_default_omission", "claim_state": "directional_model_behavior_evidence", "mission_evidence_state": "model_behavior_evidence", "model_count": 8, "row_count": 216, "total_model_output_row_count": 216, "measured_model_output_row_count": 214, "unavailable_model_output_row_count": 2, "score_bearing_row_count": 214, "question_ids": [ "FRI-MU-010", "FRI-MU-011", "FRI-MU-013", "FRI-MU-048", "FRI-MU-050", "FRI-MU-052", "FRI-MU-054", "FRI-MU-056", "FRI-MU-060", "FRI-MU-062", "FRI-MU-066", "FRI-MU-067", "FRI-MU-068", "FRI-MU-070", "FRI-MU-072", "FRI-MU-073", "FRI-MU-075", "FRI-MU-076", "FRI-MU-077", "FRI-MU-083", "FRI-MU-086", "FRI-MU-089", "FRI-MU-090", "FRI-MU-093", "FRI-MU-095", "FRI-MU-096", "FRI-MU-100" ], "total_saturated_model_response_count": 214, "measured_saturated_model_response_count": 214, "saturated_model_response_count": 214, "saturated_model_response_denominator": 214, "saturated_model_response_rate": 1, "faith_secular_saturation_rate": 1, "saturated_model_response_measured_rate": 1, "saturated_model_response_total_rate": 0.9907, "saturation_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "measured_direction_model_response_denominator": 214, "target_high_model_response_count": 214, "target_low_model_response_count": 0, "target_tie_model_response_count": 0, "target_direction_unavailable_model_response_count": 0, "target_high_model_response_rate": 1, "target_low_model_response_rate": 0, "target_tie_model_response_rate": 0, "direction_evidence_state": "target_direction_counts_available", "direction_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "faith_semantic_direction_evidence_state": "semantic_option_roles_unavailable", "faith_semantic_direction_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_option_roles_not_available_in_checked_artifact" ], "directional_score_mean": 98.8375, "reason_codes": [ "allfaith_context_identity_preserved", "forced_choice_refusal_evidence", "position_bias_instrument_artifact", "saturated_model_response", "source_card_context_only_no_distribution", "source_card_identity_preserved", "source_distribution_not_required_for_current_claim" ], "degraded_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_gap_source_row_degraded_reason_codes_missing" ] } }, "faith_secular_saturation_rate": { "metric_family_id": "faith_secular_saturation_rate", "claim_state": "directional_model_behavior_evidence", "mission_evidence_state": "model_behavior_evidence", "model_count": 8, "row_count": 800, "total_model_output_row_count": 800, "measured_model_output_row_count": 722, "unavailable_model_output_row_count": 78, "score_bearing_row_count": 722, "question_ids": [ "FRI-MU-001", "FRI-MU-002", "FRI-MU-003", "FRI-MU-004", "FRI-MU-005", "FRI-MU-006", "FRI-MU-007", "FRI-MU-008", "FRI-MU-009", "FRI-MU-010", "FRI-MU-011", "FRI-MU-012", "FRI-MU-013", "FRI-MU-014", "FRI-MU-015", "FRI-MU-016", "FRI-MU-017", "FRI-MU-018", "FRI-MU-019", "FRI-MU-020", "FRI-MU-021", "FRI-MU-022", "FRI-MU-023", "FRI-MU-024", "FRI-MU-025", "FRI-MU-026", "FRI-MU-027", "FRI-MU-028", "FRI-MU-029", "FRI-MU-030", "FRI-MU-031", "FRI-MU-032", "FRI-MU-033", "FRI-MU-034", "FRI-MU-035", "FRI-MU-036", "FRI-MU-037", "FRI-MU-038", "FRI-MU-039", "FRI-MU-040", "FRI-MU-041", "FRI-MU-042", "FRI-MU-043", "FRI-MU-044", "FRI-MU-045", "FRI-MU-046", "FRI-MU-047", "FRI-MU-048", "FRI-MU-049", "FRI-MU-050", "FRI-MU-051", "FRI-MU-052", "FRI-MU-053", "FRI-MU-054", "FRI-MU-055", "FRI-MU-056", "FRI-MU-057", "FRI-MU-058", "FRI-MU-059", "FRI-MU-060", "FRI-MU-061", "FRI-MU-062", "FRI-MU-063", "FRI-MU-064", "FRI-MU-065", "FRI-MU-066", "FRI-MU-067", "FRI-MU-068", "FRI-MU-069", "FRI-MU-070", "FRI-MU-071", "FRI-MU-072", "FRI-MU-073", "FRI-MU-074", "FRI-MU-075", "FRI-MU-076", "FRI-MU-077", "FRI-MU-078", "FRI-MU-079", "FRI-MU-080", "FRI-MU-081", "FRI-MU-082", "FRI-MU-083", "FRI-MU-084", "FRI-MU-085", "FRI-MU-086", "FRI-MU-087", "FRI-MU-088", "FRI-MU-089", "FRI-MU-090", "FRI-MU-091", "FRI-MU-092", "FRI-MU-093", "FRI-MU-094", "FRI-MU-095", "FRI-MU-096", "FRI-MU-097", "FRI-MU-098", "FRI-MU-099", "FRI-MU-100" ], "total_saturated_model_response_count": 704, "measured_saturated_model_response_count": 704, "saturated_model_response_count": 704, "saturated_model_response_denominator": 722, "saturated_model_response_rate": 0.9751, "faith_secular_saturation_rate": 0.9751, "saturated_model_response_measured_rate": 0.9751, "saturated_model_response_total_rate": 0.88, "saturation_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "measured_direction_model_response_denominator": 722, "target_high_model_response_count": 691, "target_low_model_response_count": 31, "target_tie_model_response_count": 0, "target_direction_unavailable_model_response_count": 0, "target_high_model_response_rate": 0.9571, "target_low_model_response_rate": 0.0429, "target_tie_model_response_rate": 0, "direction_evidence_state": "target_direction_counts_available", "direction_evidence_scope": "measured_model_output_rows", "faith_semantic_direction_evidence_state": "semantic_option_roles_unavailable", "faith_semantic_direction_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_option_roles_not_available_in_checked_artifact" ], "directional_score_mean": 91.1125, "reason_codes": [ "allfaith_context_identity_preserved", "false_certainty_finding", "forced_choice_compliance_degraded", "forced_choice_refusal_evidence", "human_model_divergence_finding", "missing", "not_rankable_between_models", "position_bias_instrument_artifact", "proximate_distribution", "rankable_between_models", "saturated_model_response", "some_unparseable_responses", "source_card_context_only_no_distribution", "source_card_identity_preserved", "source_context_only", "source_distribution_available", "source_distribution_not_required_for_current_claim" ], "degraded_reason_codes": [ "faith_secular_gap_source_row_degraded_reason_codes_missing" ] }, "saturation_summary": { "saturated_model_response_count": 704, "saturated_model_response_denominator": 722, "saturated_model_response_rate": 0.9751 }, "reason_codes": [ "false_certainty_finding", "forced_choice_compliance_degraded", "forced_choice_refusal_evidence", "human_model_divergence_finding", "position_bias_instrument_artifact", "saturated_model_response", "some_unparseable_responses" ], "degraded_reason_codes": [ "axis_affirming_is_scoring_polarity_not_global_semantics", "faith_secular_gap_source_row_degraded_reason_codes_missing" ] }, "links": { "index": "https://fri.faithandmedia.dev/api/v1/index.json", "report_html": "https://fri.faithandmedia.dev/core/#faith-secular-gap", "report_access": "authenticated" } }